Deanna McAtee

4209 Old Banyan Way

Sanibel, FL
$ 1,195,000 Beds 3 Baths 2.5 Sq 2,146 Virtual Tour
Monthly Estimate* How much can I afford?

Nestled within the highly sought-after Gulf Pines community, this charming 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of privacy, nature, and timeless Sanibel character. Tucked away among lush native vegetation, Gulf Pines is known for its peaceful setting, Old Florida feel, and spacious homesites—creating a true island retreat. Step inside and discover a comfortable and inviting layout designed for easy coastal living, with generous living spaces and a natural flow that makes both everyday living and entertaining a breeze. Whether you’re hosting friends or enjoying a quiet evening at home, this residence captures the relaxed elegance that defines life on Sanibel. Gulf Pines residents enjoy exclusive access to a beautifully maintained community clubhouse—perfect for gatherings and social events—Two swimming pools, as well as tennis courts for an active island lifestyle. Meandering paths wind through the neighborhood, leading you directly to one of Sanibel’s most breathtaking stretches of beach, where shelling, sunsets, and the soothing sound of the Gulf become part of your daily routine. Living here means embracing the very best of the Sanibel lifestyle—morning bike rides along scenic paths, afternoons on the beach, and evenings surrounded by nature’s beauty. If you’ve been searching for a home that offers both tranquility and connection to everything that makes Sanibel so special, this Gulf Pines gem is your opportunity to start. Helping you live the sunshine you’ve been dreaming of!

Active

  • Price
  • $ 1,195,000
  • City
  • Sanibel
  • Bedrooms
  • 3
  • Full Bathrooms
  • 2
  • County
  • Lee
  • Half Bathrooms
  • 1
  • Area
  • SI01 - Sanibel Island
  • Lot Size
  • 0.359 Acres
  • Zip
  • 33957
  • Sqr Footage
  • 2,146
  • Year Built
  • 1989
  • Taxes
  • $ 9547
  • Style
  • Contemporary, Two Story
  • MLS#
  • 2026010117
Listed By: Pfeifer Realty Group LLC
Data Source: Florida Gulf Coast MLS (SWFLMLS)

Features

General

Sewer Public Sewer
Heating Central,Electric
Cooling Central Air,Ceiling Fan(s),Electric,Zoned
Utilities Cable Available,High Speed Internet Available
Possession Close Of Escrow
Roof Shingle
Appliances Dryer,Dishwasher,Disposal,Microwave,Range,Refrigerator,Washer
Garage Spaces 2
Association Fee Includes Association Management,Insurance,Legal/Accounting,Maintenance Grounds,Pest Control,Recreation Facilities,Reserve Fund,Road Maintenance
Patio/Porch Features Lanai,Open,Porch,Screened
Architectural Style Contemporary,Two Story
Pool Features Community
Security Features Smoke Detector(s)
Construction Materials Vinyl Siding,Wood Frame
Pets Allowed Yes
Year Built 1989
View Preserve,Trees/Woods
Stories Count 2
Levels Two
Property Subtype Single Family Residence
Tax Year 2025
Ownership Single Family
Waterfront Features None
Community Features Non-Gated
HOA Fee 2 1825
County Lee
Property Type Residential
Association Amenities Beach Rights,Beach Access,Clubhouse,Pool,Tennis Court(s),Management
HOA true
Attached Garage true
Subdivision Name GULF PINES
Facing Direction East
Garage Y/N true
Full Baths 2
Status Active
Directions USE GPS
City Sanibel
Disclosures Owner Has Flood Insurance
Senior Community Y/N false
MLS Area SI01 - Sanibel Island
Lot Size Units Acres
Carport Y/N false
HOA Fee 2 Frequency Annually
Tax Annual Amount 9547
Property Condition Resale
Virtual Tour https://tour.realtoursswfl.com/sites/rvwxvqad/unbranded
Standard Status Active
Tax Lot 24
Virtual Tour https://tour.realtoursswfl.com/videos/019d0b11-4af3-7342-80bf-3ee74e50f795
Property Sub Type Additional Single Family Residence
PostalCity Sanibel
Legal Description GULF PINES 2 UNREC OR 912 PG 756 LOT 24

Interior Features

Interior Amenities Breakfast Bar,Built-in Features,Bathtub,Dual Sinks,Entrance Foyer,Eat-in Kitchen,French Door(s)/Atrium Door(s),High Ceilings,Living/Dining Room,Custom Mirrors,Main Level Primary,Separate Shower,Cable TV,Walk-In Closet(s),Window Treatments,Central Vacuum
Flooring Carpet,Tile,Wood
Furnished Y/N Partially
Total Stories 2
Air Conditioning Y/N true
Heating Y/N true
Window Features Jalousie,Display Window(s),Sliding,Impact Glass,Window Coverings
Half Baths 1
Laundry Features Inside,Laundry Tub
Total Bedrooms 3
Room Type Screened Porch
LivingAreaSource Appraiser
Total Baths 3

Exterior Features

Gulf Access false
Exterior Amenities Outdoor Shower
Parking Features Attached,Driveway,Garage,Unpaved,Garage Door Opener
Lot Features Irregular Lot,Cul-De-Sac
Water Source Public
Lot Size Area 0.359
Foundation Details Pillar/Post/Pier,Raised
Spa false
Building Area Total 4135
Lot Dimensions 113 x 197 x 78 x 139
Lot Size Acres 0.359
Private Pool false
Lot Size Source Appraiser
Waterfront Y/N false
Covered Spaces 2
Door Features French Doors
LotDimensionsSource Appraiser

Amenities

  • Foreclosure
  • Views
  • Short Sale
  • New Construction
  • Adult 55+
  • Lease To Own
  • No HOA Fees
  • Furnished
  • Primary On Main
  • Air Conditioning
  • Seller Finance
  • Green
  • Fixer Upper
  • Horse
  • Golf
  • Fireplace
  • Deck
  • Garage
  • Basement
  • Pool

Affordability Calculator

$3,786

Per Month

Based on the average sale price from the Cape Coral, FL office

  • Monthly Principal & interest $2,658
  • Monthly Property Taxes $1,062
  • Monthly Home Insurance $67
Adjust Payment Options
Agent Photo

Let's determine your purchasing power. Working with my mortgage partner, you'll have the information you need to shop for a home with confidence.

Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.49% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA, or jumbo loans.

Mortgage calculator provided courtesy of Inside Real Estate.

Schools

Elementary School Unknown Elementary School
Middle School Unknown Middle School
High School Unknown High School

Price History

4/15/2026 Listed $1,250,000
6/23/2026 4% - $1,195,000

Property vs Zip Code Average in 33957

Price
AVG $1.58M
$1.2M
Taxes
AVG $12,925
$9,547
Year Built
AVG 1987
1989

In The Neighborhood

Areas That We Cover

4209 Old Banyan Way Sanibel, FL is a Single Family Home for sale at $1195000 with 2146 sqft and a lot size of 0.359 Acres Acre(s). 4209 Old Banyan Way Sanibel has 3 bedrooms, 2 baths and was built in 1989. The property's zip code is 33957 which is in Sanibel, FL

*Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Financial calculator disclaimer: Default based on a 30-year fixed rate of 6.49% with 20% down. The estimated payment is offered for convenience and is not an offer of credit. Due to market fluctuations, interest rates are subject to change at any time and without notice. Your individual rate may vary. Rates may differ for FHA, VA or jumbo loans.

Mortgage calculator provided courtesy of Inside Real Estate.

All information deemed reliable, but not guaranteed, and should be independently verified. The real estate information and related content displayed on this site is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

Deanna McAtee

Deanna McAtee

406-871-4950

By pressing Contact Me, you agree that Weichert® may contact you via phone about your inquiry, which may involve the use of automated means. You are not required to consent as a condition of purchasing any property, goods or services. For any other information please read our Privacy Policy